Re-evaluation of solutions to the problem of unprofessionalism in peer review
Description
The paper found that 43% of peer-review comments contained unprofessional or unsubstantiated critiques, sparking discussions on social media. While most online reactions were positive, some negative comments justified unprofessional behavior, citing concerns that forced niceness would lead to poor-quality science. The authors argue that these rationales perpetuate a toxic peer-review culture and advocate for prioritizing professionalism.